Migration tool failing to detect AngularJS components

When using the Angular Upgrade (ngUpgrade) module to migrate an AngularJS application to Angular, the migration tool may fail to detect AngularJS components for various reasons. This can occur due to a mismatch in configurations, incorrect setup, or issues in the way components are registered.

Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to troubleshoot and resolve issues where the migration tool fails to detect AngularJS components during the migration process:

---

1. Confirm Proper Setup of ngUpgrade Module

Before diagnosing specific issues with AngularJS components, ensure that your app is correctly set up for migration using the ngUpgrade module. The migration tool uses this module to enable communication between AngularJS and Angular.

Check the Installation

Make sure that both AngularJS and Angular dependencies are correctly installed and that the ngUpgrade package is included:

• Install Angular and AngularJS: npm install @angular/upgrade @angular/core angular
• Add ngUpgrade to your Angular app’s dependencies: import { UpgradeModule } from '@angular/upgrade/static';
• Import the UpgradeModule in your Angular root module: @NgModule({ imports: [ UpgradeModule, // other modules ], // other configurations }) export class AppModule { constructor(private upgrade: UpgradeModule) {} }

---

2. Ensure Correct Component Downgrading

In hybrid applications, Angular components need to be downgraded to be usable within the AngularJS environment. The migration tool uses downgradeComponent to achieve this. If components aren’t detected, there may be an issue in the downgrade process.

Downgrade Angular Component

Ensure that you are correctly downgrading the Angular component using the downgradeComponent function from ngUpgrade:

import { downgradeComponent } from '@angular/upgrade/static';
import { MyAngularComponent } from './my-angular-component.component';

angular.module('myApp').directive(
  'myAngularComponent',
  downgradeComponent({ component: MyAngularComponent })
);

• Component Registration: Ensure that the component is registered properly with AngularJS by using angular.module('myApp').directive().
• Downgrade Syntax: Double-check that the downgradeComponent syntax is correct. If the component is not correctly downgraded, AngularJS will not recognize it.

---

3. Confirm Component Selector

Make sure that the component selector in Angular is correctly used in AngularJS templates. If there’s a mismatch between the Angular component’s selector and the way it’s referenced in the AngularJS templates, the component will not be recognized.

For example:

• Angular Component: @Component({ selector: 'app-my-angular-component', template: '<h1>My Angular Component</h1>', }) export class MyAngularComponent {}
• AngularJS Template: In your AngularJS template or directive, ensure you use the correct selector: <app-my-angular-component></app-my-angular-component>

If the selector in Angular does not match how it’s used in AngularJS, the migration tool may fail to detect it.

---

4. Component Registration in AngularJS

AngularJS components must be correctly registered within the AngularJS app for the ngUpgrade migration to recognize them.

Ensure that your AngularJS components are defined properly:

• AngularJS Component Definition: angular.module('myApp').component('myAngularJsComponent', { templateUrl: 'app/my-angularjs-component.html', controller: function() { // component logic } });

If AngularJS components are not registered correctly, Angular may fail to interact with them during the migration.

---

5. Check for Name Mismatches

When downgrading Angular components, ensure that there is no name mismatch between Angular and AngularJS. Angular components use camelCase or PascalCase, while AngularJS components use kebab-case in HTML templates.

For example:

• Angular: MyAngularComponent
• AngularJS: my-angular-component

Ensure the Angular component’s selector matches the kebab-case convention used in AngularJS templates:

<my-angular-component></my-angular-component>

---

6. Check for Compatibility Between AngularJS and Angular Versions

Sometimes, issues with component detection arise due to compatibility problems between the versions of AngularJS and Angular you are using. Ensure that the versions are compatible with the ngUpgrade module.

• Angular 10+ works with AngularJS 1.7.x, but it is important to ensure you are using a compatible version of both libraries. Incompatibilities between major versions may prevent the migration tool from detecting components.

To resolve version conflicts, make sure that you’re using supported versions of both AngularJS and Angular.

---

7. Ensure ngUpgrade Bootstrap

If the application bootstrap process is not properly configured, the Angular components may fail to load correctly in AngularJS. The bootstrap process should use upgrade.bootstrap to initialize both AngularJS and Angular within the same page.

For example:

import { platformBrowserDynamic } from '@angular/platform-browser-dynamic';
import { UpgradeModule } from '@angular/upgrade/static';
import { AppModule } from './app/app.module';

platformBrowserDynamic()
  .bootstrapModule(AppModule)
  .then((ref) => {
    const upgrade = ref.injector.get(UpgradeModule);
    upgrade.bootstrap(document.body, ['myApp'], { strictDi: true });
  })
  .catch((err) => console.error(err));

This ensures that Angular and AngularJS share the same bootstrapping process, and AngularJS components are detected correctly.

---

8. Check for AngularJS $injector Conflicts

Sometimes, $injector issues can prevent the migration tool from detecting components, especially if AngularJS services are not correctly upgraded or injected. Ensure that AngularJS services are upgraded and properly injected into Angular components.

You can use the downgradeInjectable method to downgrade Angular services to AngularJS:

import { downgradeInjectable } from '@angular/upgrade/static';
import { MyAngularService } from './my-angular-service.service';

angular.module('myApp').factory('myAngularService', downgradeInjectable(MyAngularService));

---

9. Use ngUpgrade Logging for Debugging

To diagnose what might be going wrong, enable logging in the AngularJS and Angular app. Check the browser console for errors related to the migration, and ensure that AngularJS components are correctly initialized.

You can use the following approach to log AngularJS component registration:

console.log(angular.module('myApp').component('myAngularJsComponent'));

Also, check the console for any ngUpgrade related warnings or errors, which may help you pinpoint the issue.

---