Both ng-if
and ng-show/ng-hide
are used for conditionally displaying elements in AngularJS, but they have different behaviors and impact performance in different ways.
1. Key Differences Between ng-if
and ng-show/ng-hide
Feature | ng-if | ng-show / ng-hide |
---|---|---|
DOM Manipulation | Adds/removes elements from the DOM | Only changes the display CSS property (keeps the element in the DOM) |
Performance Impact | Higher impact if used frequently (DOM re-creation) | Lower impact since elements remain in the DOM |
Scope Handling | Scope is destroyed and recreated | Scope remains active |
Use Case | Best for elements that appear/disappear infrequently | Best for toggling visibility without destroying data |
2. Performance Considerations
ng-if
(Better for Memory Usage)
- Removes and re-creates elements from the DOM when the condition changes.
- When an element is removed, its child elements, bindings, and watchers are destroyed.
- Helps reduce memory usage when elements are no longer needed.
- Performance Issue: Frequent toggling leads to unnecessary re-creation of elements, causing lag.
Example:
<div ng-if="isVisible">
<h2>This element is created only when `isVisible` is true.</h2>
</div>
When to Use ng-if
?
- When an element should be completely removed from the DOM when not needed.
- When reducing memory consumption is a priority.
- When dealing with large data sets or complex UI elements that should not persist when hidden.
ng-show
/ ng-hide
(Better for UI Performance)
- Only modifies CSS (
display: none;
), so the element remains in the DOM. - The scope and event listeners remain active, reducing DOM manipulation.
- Performance Issue: More watchers remain active, leading to increased CPU usage if used on too many elements.
Example:
<div ng-show="isVisible">
<h2>This element remains in the DOM but is hidden when `isVisible` is false.</h2>
</div>
When to Use ng-show
/ ng-hide
?
- When you need to frequently toggle visibility without destroying the element.
- When elements contain input fields, animations, or data that should not be lost when hidden.
- When performance is more about reducing DOM re-renders rather than memory usage.
3. Performance Benchmarks: When to Choose What?
Scenario | Use ng-if | Use ng-show/ng-hide |
---|---|---|
Rendering large lists | (prevents unnecessary memory usage) | (keeps hidden elements in memory) |
Frequently toggling elements | (high DOM manipulation overhead) | (no re-creation, just toggles visibility) |
Forms with input fields | (destroys data and input fields) | (keeps user inputs intact) |
Modal pop-ups | (destroys and recreates modal for better memory management) | (if keeping form inputs and animations) |
Navigation menus | (if menu is rarely used) | (if toggled often) |
4. Best Practices for Optimizing Performance
Use ng-if
for heavy UI elements that are rarely shown.
Use ng-show/ng-hide
for UI elements that toggle frequently but should remain in memory.
Minimize the number of watchers by combining conditions in a controller.
Use track by
in ng-repeat
to optimize re-renders if ng-if
is used inside loops.
Consider lazy loading for large components instead of keeping them hidden.
Final Verdict
- Use
ng-if
when you want to reduce memory usage by destroying elements when not needed. - Use
ng-show
/ng-hide
when you want better UI performance by keeping elements in memory.
Let me know if you need more details!