ng-if vs. ng-show/ng-hide performance issue

Loading

Both ng-if and ng-show/ng-hide are used for conditionally displaying elements in AngularJS, but they have different behaviors and impact performance in different ways.


1. Key Differences Between ng-if and ng-show/ng-hide

Featureng-ifng-show / ng-hide
DOM ManipulationAdds/removes elements from the DOMOnly changes the display CSS property (keeps the element in the DOM)
Performance ImpactHigher impact if used frequently (DOM re-creation)Lower impact since elements remain in the DOM
Scope HandlingScope is destroyed and recreatedScope remains active
Use CaseBest for elements that appear/disappear infrequentlyBest for toggling visibility without destroying data

2. Performance Considerations

ng-if (Better for Memory Usage)

  • Removes and re-creates elements from the DOM when the condition changes.
  • When an element is removed, its child elements, bindings, and watchers are destroyed.
  • Helps reduce memory usage when elements are no longer needed.
  • Performance Issue: Frequent toggling leads to unnecessary re-creation of elements, causing lag.

Example:

<div ng-if="isVisible">
<h2>This element is created only when `isVisible` is true.</h2>
</div>

When to Use ng-if?

  • When an element should be completely removed from the DOM when not needed.
  • When reducing memory consumption is a priority.
  • When dealing with large data sets or complex UI elements that should not persist when hidden.

ng-show / ng-hide (Better for UI Performance)

  • Only modifies CSS (display: none;), so the element remains in the DOM.
  • The scope and event listeners remain active, reducing DOM manipulation.
  • Performance Issue: More watchers remain active, leading to increased CPU usage if used on too many elements.

Example:

<div ng-show="isVisible">
<h2>This element remains in the DOM but is hidden when `isVisible` is false.</h2>
</div>

When to Use ng-show / ng-hide?

  • When you need to frequently toggle visibility without destroying the element.
  • When elements contain input fields, animations, or data that should not be lost when hidden.
  • When performance is more about reducing DOM re-renders rather than memory usage.

3. Performance Benchmarks: When to Choose What?

ScenarioUse ng-ifUse ng-show/ng-hide
Rendering large lists (prevents unnecessary memory usage) (keeps hidden elements in memory)
Frequently toggling elements (high DOM manipulation overhead) (no re-creation, just toggles visibility)
Forms with input fields (destroys data and input fields) (keeps user inputs intact)
Modal pop-ups (destroys and recreates modal for better memory management) (if keeping form inputs and animations)
Navigation menus (if menu is rarely used) (if toggled often)

4. Best Practices for Optimizing Performance

Use ng-if for heavy UI elements that are rarely shown.
Use ng-show/ng-hide for UI elements that toggle frequently but should remain in memory.
Minimize the number of watchers by combining conditions in a controller.
Use track by in ng-repeat to optimize re-renders if ng-if is used inside loops.
Consider lazy loading for large components instead of keeping them hidden.


Final Verdict

  • Use ng-if when you want to reduce memory usage by destroying elements when not needed.
  • Use ng-show/ng-hide when you want better UI performance by keeping elements in memory.

Let me know if you need more details!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *