$rootScope conflicts in hybrid AngularJS-Angular apps

In hybrid AngularJS-Angular apps, $rootScope conflicts arise because Angular (version 2+) no longer uses $rootScope, and the usage of $rootScope in AngularJS can clash with the new mechanisms of Angular. In a hybrid application, which combines AngularJS (1.x) and Angular (2+), both frameworks are operating simultaneously, leading to potential issues if both frameworks are trying to manage the same application state or communication mechanisms.

Here’s an in-depth explanation of the conflicts that can arise and how to resolve them:

---

1. Differences in How AngularJS and Angular Manage Global States

• AngularJS uses $rootScope as a global object that stores properties and methods accessible across all controllers and directives. It is essentially a global event bus in AngularJS and allows broadcasting of events and sharing data across the application.
• Angular (2+) uses services and state management systems (e.g., NgRx, Akita) to manage the global application state. Angular’s architecture encourages using dependency injection (DI) to manage and share data and services between components, rather than relying on a global $rootScope.

2. Hybrid Application Challenges

When migrating or running an application in hybrid mode, both AngularJS and Angular coexist. As both frameworks are trying to manage state in their respective ways, conflicts can arise:

• Overriding global state: Both AngularJS and Angular might try to control the same global state, leading to confusion or unexpected behavior.
• Event propagation conflicts: AngularJS uses $broadcast, $emit, and $on for event communication through the $rootScope, while Angular uses services or a more modular event system like RxJS and EventEmitter. These mechanisms can conflict with each other when hybridization is involved.
• Dirty checking and change detection: AngularJS’s $digest cycle for detecting changes conflicts with Angular’s change detection strategy, leading to potential performance bottlenecks, especially when $rootScope is heavily used.

---

3. Solutions and Best Practices

To resolve conflicts between $rootScope in AngularJS and global state management in Angular, follow these best practices:

---

3.1 Avoid Using $rootScope in Angular

While migrating, avoid introducing new logic that depends on $rootScope in the AngularJS part of your hybrid app. If you need to share state across components in Angular, prefer using Angular services and dependency injection (DI).

For example, instead of using $rootScope to store a user’s authentication status, use an Angular service like this:

@Injectable({
  providedIn: 'root',
})
export class AuthService {
  private isAuthenticated = false;

  constructor() {}

  setAuthStatus(status: boolean) {
    this.isAuthenticated = status;
  }

  getAuthStatus(): boolean {
    return this.isAuthenticated;
  }
}

You can inject this service into your components or directives to manage authentication state.

3.2 Integrating AngularJS $rootScope with Angular Services

If you still need to use $rootScope for some specific reason, you can bridge the gap by integrating AngularJS $rootScope with Angular services or Angular’s DI system.

For example, you can create a wrapper service around $rootScope in AngularJS:

@Injectable({
  providedIn: 'root',
})
export class AngularJSRootScopeWrapperService {
  constructor() {
    // @ts-ignore - Allowing access to the AngularJS $rootScope
    this.$rootScope = angular.element(document.body).injector().get('$rootScope');
  }

  set(key: string, value: any) {
    this.$rootScope[key] = value;
  }

  get(key: string) {
    return this.$rootScope[key];
  }
}

With this approach, you can access $rootScope using Angular’s DI system without directly manipulating $rootScope in your Angular code, making it easier to control the interaction between AngularJS and Angular.

3.3 Use $rootScope for AngularJS-Specific Logic Only

If you need to communicate between AngularJS and Angular, limit the usage of $rootScope to just the AngularJS part of your app. Avoid directly manipulating $rootScope in Angular components or services.

You can pass data from AngularJS to Angular components through Angular services or by using the ngUpgrade services like downgradeComponent and downgradeInjectable. This allows you to ensure that Angular and AngularJS components can communicate without relying on $rootScope.

---

3.4 Manage Events in Hybrid Apps Carefully

AngularJS’s event system ($emit, $broadcast, $on) does not directly map to Angular’s system. In Angular, you use EventEmitter with the @Output decorator to communicate from a component to its parent.

For hybrid apps, consider using RxJS Observables for communication between AngularJS and Angular components. RxJS can act as a bridge between both parts of your application.

For example, you can use an RxJS subject to share state across both AngularJS and Angular components:

import { Subject } from 'rxjs';

@Injectable({
  providedIn: 'root',
})
export class SharedService {
  private subject = new Subject<any>();

  sendMessage(message: string) {
    this.subject.next(message);
  }

  getMessage() {
    return this.subject.asObservable();
  }
}

With this approach, AngularJS components can communicate via the SharedService, which acts as a mediator between Angular and AngularJS.

3.5 Optimize Change Detection Between AngularJS and Angular

Both AngularJS and Angular have their own change detection mechanisms. AngularJS uses the $digest cycle, while Angular uses a more efficient unidirectional change detection. When hybridizing, frequent re-renders can be a performance issue.

To solve this:

• Minimize reliance on $rootScope: As mentioned earlier, shift logic into Angular services. This reduces the number of times AngularJS’s $digest cycle is triggered.
• Use Angular’s ngUpgrade carefully: When upgrading, use the ngUpgrade module’s downgradeComponent and downgradeInjectable to integrate Angular components and services into the AngularJS app, while minimizing conflicts with $rootScope.

---

3.6 Keep Communication Between AngularJS and Angular Clear

When using Angular and AngularJS together, it’s important to keep the lines of communication clear:

• Use services for communication rather than relying on $rootScope.
• Consider downgrading Angular components or services for use in AngularJS using downgradeComponent.
• Use AngularJS directives and Angular components separately, without overlapping responsibilities.

---

4. Example: Downgrading Angular Service for AngularJS Use

Here’s how you might downgrade an Angular service so that AngularJS can use it:

import { Injectable } from '@angular/core';
import { downgradeInjectable } from '@angular/upgrade/static';

@Injectable({
  providedIn: 'root',
})
export class MyAngularService {
  getData() {
    return 'Data from Angular service';
  }
}

// Downgrade Angular service for AngularJS use
angular.module('app').factory('myAngularService', downgradeInjectable(MyAngularService));

In your AngularJS controller, you can now inject and use this service like any other AngularJS service.

---